Skip to main content

Should I call my insurance company or a lawyer first after a car accident in New York?

Sponsored Answer
Slawomir Platta - Personal Injury - General - Super Lawyers

Answered by: Slawomir Platta

Located in New York, NYThe Platta Law Firm

Phone: 917-920-4284
Fax: 212-514-9300

View Profile

While it is important to communicate any accident information to your insurance company, there are some important details to consider first.

Emergency Medical Care Is The Highest Immediate Priority

At the scene of the accident, the first thing you should do is make sure you are not seriously injured. If you have any doubt at all, call 911 and seek immediate medical attention. Similarly, if anyone at the scene might be hurt, call emergency services to get the appropriate emergency medical care for anyone who needs it.

The Delicate Relationship With Your Insurance Company

On the micro level, your insurance company is obligated to provide you with whatever coverage is contractually agreed upon in the insurance policy language. In that respect, your insurance company is there to help you and cover the costs associated with medical care, property damages and the like, insofar as you are covered for those things. The only exception comes with operating a motorcycle, for which injuries fall under a separate insurance policy.

On a larger scale, however, it is important to understand that insurance companies exist as for-profit organizations. Their primary goal is to make money. To this end, insurance companies are motivated to minimize or deny coverage whenever possible. Paying out less on claims protects their bottom lines.

Conflict Of Interests

The insurance company’s contract with you and its overall goal of making money and minimizing expenses results in a conflict of interest. In so far as the insurance company wants to avoid expenditures, it will be motivated to minimize the payments on your viable insurance claim. Even truck drivers with large liability insurance policies are treated no different. 

Because of this conflict of interest, the insurance company is not always on your side.

How A Lawyer Can Protect You

The problem with talking to your insurance adjuster is that everything you say can be noted and used against you. For example, if you tell your insurance agent that you’re “feeling much better” or admit to some degree of fault in the accident, the insurance company could use that to deny your claim.

A skilled and experienced attorney will know the nuances involved in talking with the insurance company on your behalf. An attorney will not have a conflict of interest when representing you before the insurance company, and they will not say anything that will reduce your compensation.

Call Your Attorney First

It is critical to call your lawyer first before you talk with your insurance agent. After an accident, seek immediate medical care and then contact an experienced motor vehicle accident lawyer as soon as possible.

Other Answers By Slawomir Platta

Photo of Slawomir Platta

Can I sue for a New York construction accident if I am not in a union?

The short answer is: Yes.A Common Misconception Because of the prevalence and importance of unions, it is easy to …

Sponsored answer by Slawomir Platta

Other Answers About Motor Vehicle Accidents

Photo of Paul R. Dahlberg

I was hurt in a motorcycle crash in Minnesota. Does insurance cover me?

Motorcyclists are highly vulnerable when crossing paths with negligent drivers. Many riders are killed or suffer …

Sponsored answer by Paul R. Dahlberg

Photo of Andrew Lampros

Can I Sue If I’m Injured In A Car Crash In Georgia?

If you were injured in a motor vehicle crash due to someone else’s negligence, you might be able to file a …

Sponsored answer by Andrew Lampros

Photo of Paul R. Dahlberg

Can I Sue An Uninsured Driver After A Motor Vehicle Accident In Minnesota?

While it is possible to sue an uninsured driver if you’ve been injured due to their negligence, it is …

Sponsored answer by Paul R. Dahlberg

Call Me

To: Slawomir Platta

Super Lawyers: Potential Client Inquiry

Required fields are marked with an asterisk (*).


The information contained in this web site is intended to convey general information. It should not be construed as legal advice or opinion. It is not an offer to represent you, nor is it intended to create an attorney-client relationship. The use of the internet or this contact form for communication is not necessarily a secure environment. Contacting a lawyer or law firm email through this service will not create an attorney-client relationship, and information will not necessarily be treated as privileged or confidential.

Page Generated: 0.73809599876404 sec