What to Know About Price-Gouging and Price-Fixing in a Crisis
Some New Yorkers learned the hard way during COVID
on October 29, 2020
Updated on May 17, 2022
On Jan. 31, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services declared a national public health emergency, which subsequently triggered Section 396-R, the New York price gouging statute that protects goods and services vital for consumers’ health, safety and welfare. Additionally, on March 16, the NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection enacted an emergency rule making price gouging illegal for products needed to prevent the spread of the virus.
But that didn’t stop wrongdoers.
A Manhattan hardware store was cited for charging $80 for hand sanitizer; a Queens grocer got in trouble for charging $15 for disinfectant spray; and an Upper East Side pharmacy was cited for selling 20 face masks for $200. By March 25, the city had issued more than 1,000 violations related to COVID-19 price gouging.
“Simply put, price gouging is an unconscionable, unethical act,” says Gregory Asciolla, a partner at Labaton Sucharow. “It involves taking advantage of the most vulnerable during a crisis—like a natural disaster or a public health emergency such as COVID-19—in order to make a quick, excessive profit by selling essential products and services at exorbitant prices.”
More often than not, price gouging is obvious, Asciolla adds. You just need to look at the most necessary products during an emergency—disinfectants, face masks and hand sanitizer, in this case—and watch prices skyrocket. “If they walk into a store and see a roll of toilet paper for $14, a consumer is going to say, ‘Wait a second. This should’ve been 75 cents. That’s what I paid before this emergency,’” he says.
State Laws on Market Pricing & Price-Gouging Complaints
Price gouging is under state jurisdiction in New York, “so if somebody sees or experiences price gouging activity, whether they’re 100% certain or not, they would want to report that to the attorney general, which right now is Letitia James. The office will investigate and prosecute any price gouging that they see,” Asciolla says.
Then there’s price fixing, which falls under antitrust laws and involves collaboration among competitors. This one is usually less obvious.
“The prices don’t necessarily go up thousands of percent,” Asciolla says. “At times there is evidence, and consumers may notice that every six months the price goes up by all the manufacturers by the exact same amount. And they say, ‘This is suspicious.’ Price-fixing conspiracies are more nuanced, more difficult to find, because with a conspiracy, the whole purpose is to keep it secret.”
Do I Go to the Attorney General’s Office or a Law Firm?
In these cases, you can seek out the AG or a private attorney to look into it. “The issue is whether or not you can establish an unfair or deceptive trade practice. Was the pricing extreme or artificial?” says Joseph P. Guglielmo, an attorney at Scott+Scott Attorneys at Law. “You have to look into the specific party, and whether or not the pricing is out of whack compared to demand or supply.”
As part of an investigation, Guglielmo says an attorney might look at supply and demand data and pricing fluctuations for both the product and its raw materials. “In a time like this,” he says, “there are going to be price increases for products in scarce supply. The question is: Did manufacturers or suppliers or other involved entities take advantage of the situation to create shortages or supply-and-demand issues?”
So how does all that apply to the coronavirus pandemic? In a past case Guglielmo’s firm alleged that aluminum suppliers created an artificial demand by restricting output. “That’s an example of what to look at today,” Guglielmo says.
Here’s another example: “N95 masks used to cost $1 or $2, say, and you could find them almost anywhere,” he says. “So if you’re a hospital or consumer trying to buy them during COVID-19, then maybe the demand has raised the price to $4. But are there people selling them at $20 or $200? Are they rationing them and creating black markets?”
Whether it’s price gouging or fixing, consumers are the ones who pay, and who, in the case of COVID-19, are put at further risk. The good news is there’s help.
“If you’re a business or consumer and suspect something is going on with pricing, especially if you think it’s systemic and not an isolated incident, go to an attorney and see if they think it’s worth looking into,” Guglielmo says.
For more information on this area of law, see our overview of antitrust litigation.