A Conversation With Nine Other Human Beings

John Neiman on clerking for and arguing before the U.S. Supreme Court

Published in 2026 Mid-South Super Lawyers magazine

By Jessica Glynn on November 17, 2026

Share:

A few days before delivering his first oral argument before the U.S. Supreme Court in 2011, John Neiman, solicitor general of Alabama, took questions from students after a moot trial at Georgetown’s Supreme Court Institute. One question, it turned out, was more personal than the norm.  

“I looked at your bio,” the student said, “and saw that you clerked for Justice Anthony Kennedy. Are you nervous about arguing in front of him?”

Neiman had definitely been thinking about this first appearance before his old boss; but their history gave him comfort rather than anxiety. “It was such a professional experience and relationship that, in my mind, arguing in front of the justice would not be that different from serving as his law clerk,” Neiman told the student. “It would involve the same sort of conversation as when we discussed cases—where he would ask questions designed to help me think through the issues.”

But Neiman said he was nervous about arguing in front of his former law professor, Justice Elena Kagan, with whom he had a friendly relationship. “Unlike the purely law clerk/justice relationship I had with Justice Kennedy, I thought it would be nerve-wracking to have her be a justice asking me questions in a very serious case.”

Maples v. Thomas involved a death row inmate, Cory Maples, who had missed an appeal deadline because his lawyers had left their firm. 

“Was his failure to file the appeal on time excused by the fact that these attorneys had left their office in New York without making appropriate arrangements?” Neiman says. “Our argument was that under a clear U.S. Supreme Court precedent [Coleman v. Thompson], the death row inmate ultimately was responsible for the actions of his attorney, and a failure to file an appeal in a timely way is a jurisdictional failure that led to the loss of his ability to challenge his conviction or sentence.”

On the morning of his argument, Neiman arrived with Alabama Attorney General Luther Strange at 7:30 a.m.—foolishly early, he feels, given the doors were still locked and they had nothing to do but wait and be nervous. Once in the building, they had to wait around for the lawyers’ lounge to open.

“I’m just killing time, looking at pictures of Justice Blackmun, and a marshal walks up to me and says, ‘Are you Mr. Neiman? Justice Kagan would like to speak with you.’ I’m thinking, ‘Why in the heck does Justice Kagan want to speak to me right before this argument?’”

It was clear she simply wanted to catch up.

“And it was the single best thing anybody could have done for me that day because it completely calmed me down,” he says. “It reminded me that all these justices, even though they are incredibly brilliant, they’re also human beings. She wasn’t wearing her black robe. She was in business attire. She’s not up on the bench. I’m not at the lectern. We’re just sitting in chairs in her office, talking about Harvard and Cambridge. I will always remember that moment with great fondness—especially because she did me no favors during the argument.”

Both Kagan and Kennedy sided with the majority in the 7-2 decision in favor of the inmate. 

“It was good to know that even though I lost that case, it wasn’t personal. It was about what the justices thought the right result should be in that case,” he says. “You prepare as well as you can, and ultimately it’s up to the justices to decide what the law and the facts require.”

That’s the perspective Neiman brought to his other U.S. Supreme Court appearance in Miller v. Alabama, a loss that ended mandatory sentencing of life without parole for juvenile homicide offenders. And he brings it to every case he litigates today as an appellate lawyer at Maynard Nexsen in Birmingham, Alabama.

“Nothing can prepare you for oral argument as well as the experience of arguing in front of the justices with the spotlight on you,” he says.

It was during his clerkship for Judge Paul Niemeyer at the U.S. Court of Appeals that Neiman received a phone call from Justice Kennedy with an offer for a U.S. Supreme Court clerkship. It was December 2000, the same month the Supreme Court ended the recount in Bush v. Gore, leaving George W. Bush as the 43rd president of the United States.

Neiman says former clerks have to be tight-lipped about cases to adhere to court ethics rules, but he’s able to speak broadly about what the court was like in the aftermath of that intensely scrutinized decision.

“The joke around the legal community in 2001 was that it was one of the most boring Supreme Court terms of all time,” he says. “The speculation, at least on the outside, was the court was looking to avoid controversy after wading into what had been a very controversial case.”

As Kennedy’s clerk, Neiman evaluated petitions for writ of certiorari and sent recommendations on which cases to take or deny—a process that was dramatically affected by another major historical event.

The morning of 9/11, Neiman remembers a clerk stopping by his office to ask if he’d heard a plane had hit the World Trade Center. At the time, there was no Wi-Fi and limited internet at the Supreme Court, so they went to chambers to watch events unfold. Once it became apparent that U.S. institutions were under attack and the justices themselves needed to seek safety, the court was evacuated. A month later, anthrax attacks forced the justices from their offices to a temporary location.

The effects were far-reaching. “I think every advocate that had to come before the court with a case that dealt with, say, the power of the government in the Fourth Amendment context—when we ask whether a particular search or seizure is reasonable—how that conduct ought to be understood in light of this new world that had been created for all of us on September 11 certainly was going to affect the analysis,” he says. “And not just in my year, but in many years to come.”

Neiman says Kennedy remained a consummate gentleman throughout those intense times.

“The principal lesson I learned from working with him was how to treat the people you work with, and especially the people who work for you,” he says. “He treated us incredibly professionally.”

Other lessons learned came from watching as many oral arguments as possible—from people like John Roberts, Jeff Sutton and Bill Pryor, before their judicial appointments.

“They pretty obviously anticipated questions and came to the argument ready to answer them,” he says. “They also answered the questions. There are many advocates who, when posed particular questions, their instinct will be to dodge the question, to change the topic if the question is difficult for them. The best advocates I saw at the court all listened intently and actually answered the question that was posed to them by the justices—even when they had to acknowledge that the answer, on its face, might point in a direction that wasn’t favorable to the client. After making whatever concessions were necessary, they would turn to the angle that got their client to victory.”

Neiman strives for the thrill of leaving an oral argument knowing he’s knocked it out of the park. But what he enjoys most about his appellate practice is sitting down with a client long before that argument to examine a verdict for issues that will best capture the attention of an appellate judge. 

In Protective Life Insurance Company v. Apex Parks Group, for example, Neiman’s client appealed an $11.2 million verdict stemming from its refusal to pay a $10 million life insurance policy on the Apex CEO.

“Anytime the verdict goes the wrong way, if you talk to the people who tried the case, they’ll always point you to 10 different reasons why they believe the judgment was wrong,” Neiman says. “We knew going in that the appellate judges are unlikely to give much credence to an argument that there were 10 separate errors in what their colleague on the trial bench had done. So we were able to isolate the one issue the bench would most likely think was a serious miscarriage of justice.”

In this case, it was the deceased misrepresenting his medical history. That argument won the day. The previous verdict was overturned unanimously by the Alabama Supreme Court without oral argument.

When it comes to oral arguments, Neiman continues to approach matters as he did before the U.S. Supreme Court—striving for the kind of back-and-forth with the justices that he enjoyed as a clerk. “It’s really just a conversation between you and three or seven or nine other human beings,” he says.

Search attorney feature articles

Featured lawyers

John C. Neiman, Jr

John C. Neiman, Jr

Top rated Appellate lawyer Maynard Nexsen PC Birmingham, AL

Other featured articles

Corrie Woods’ podcast and blog about SCOPA

The risks, rewards and legal tips if you’re considering joining a labor organization

Things to look for when selecting the best person to handle your case

View more articles featuring lawyers

Find top lawyers with confidence

The Super Lawyers patented selection process is peer influenced and research driven, selecting the top 5% of attorneys to the Super Lawyers lists each year. We know lawyers and make it easy to connect with them.

Find a lawyer near you