The Justice She Carries

A clerkship with Chief Justice Rehnquist showed Heidi Doerhoff Vollet the importance of home, the law, and punctuality

Published in 2026 Missouri & Kansas Super Lawyers magazine

By Nancy Henderson on November 12, 2026

Share:

Already intimidated by the grandeur of the U.S. Supreme Court building, with its red carpet and wood-and-gold furnishings, recent law school graduate Heidi Doerhoff Vollet was waiting in the anteroom for her clerkship interview with Chief Justice William Rehnquist when she spotted his clay bust. Like other SCOTUS sculptures, it would ultimately be finished in marble and displayed in the Great Hall. 

“It was looking quite seriously at me,” says Vollet, who now handles complex litigation and appellate cases at Cook, Vetter, Doerhoff & Landwehr in Jefferson City. 

To her relief, Rehnquist wanted to talk on topics that included the karst topography of Vollet’s home state of Missouri. “I never in a million years thought I was going to get the job, but it turned out I did,” she says. “He later told me he was trying to match up people that he thought he would enjoy working with.” 

The yearlong clerkship, which began in the summer of 2001, might not have happened without the urging of a former Rehnquist clerk and lawyer at the Washington, D.C., firm where Vollet had worked during law school. “I think he would like you,” the attorney told her. 

The feeling turned out to be mutual. Rehnquist could come across as austere, Vollet says, but he was far from the stereotypical figure she’d expected. In fact, he could be downright fun. “He liked to have bets on the weekly football game, and we played charades at his house,” Vollet says. “He had a dry sense of humor.”

Even outside the court, though, Rehnquist was a stickler for timeliness. “I struggled. I’ve always been a perennially late person,” says Vollet. “For him, being on time meant you had to arrive at exactly the moment you were supposed to be there, because if it was too early, that was wrong. But if it was late, then you were really in trouble.”

The chief justice relished weekly lunchtime tennis matches with his clerks, who were expected to meet him at the parking garage to ride to the nearby public court. One time, Vollet showed up a few minutes late. “In a very stern voice, he said, ‘Heidi, this is like the doctor’s office. You might wait for the doctor, but the doctor never waits for you.’ I was always on time after that.”

Vollet and Chief Justice Rehnquist during her clerkship.

While clerks for some of the other justices wrote speeches and provided basic assistance, those who worked for Rehnquist played major roles in analyzing cert petitions and recommending which ones merited the justice’s interest. They also occasionally drafted dissents and, more frequently, opinions—which other justices often mulled over for weeks. “We had to get our drafts done in 10 days,” Vollet says. “He felt that his decisions did not improve if he sat on them a lot longer.”

Relying on his sharp memory, Rehnquist preferred to prepare for arguments by taking walks with his clerks to discuss their assigned cases. “He was pretty solid on his views on a lot of things,” Vollet recalls. “But he certainly took into consideration our input.”

Two months into her clerkship, 9/11 shook the world. “I remember walking out of the building, very orderly, with lots of other clerks and staff and members of Congress. And there was a lot of conflicting information about maybe another plane coming toward the Capitol,” she says. 

Known for encouraging his clerks to return to their home states to practice, Rehnquist suggested Vollet  pursue Missouri’s solicitor general post. She didn’t, but she did move back home for a three-year stint at the Missouri Attorney General’s Office. The next time Vollet saw him, “I told him I’d taken his advice, and he was pleased about that.”

In many ways, Rehnquist set a wonderful precedent for her practice, Vollet says. Among his lessons: Take time for your family and outside interests; be respectful; and value teamwork. “He was so neat and engaging that you just wanted to perform really well for him. … He often led by example, and I feel that he has been one of my best mentors and models. He was the one that I carry with me.”

Search attorney feature articles

Featured lawyers

Heidi Doerhoff Vollet

Heidi Doerhoff Vollet

Top rated General Litigation lawyer Cook, Vetter, Doerhoff and Landwehr, P.C. Jefferson City, MO

Other featured articles

How to help your internet startup dodge litigation landmines

What does it take to start a tax-exempt org?

The rules and regulations to prepare for in the marijuana, hemp and CBD space

View more articles featuring lawyers

Find top lawyers with confidence

The Super Lawyers patented selection process is peer influenced and research driven, selecting the top 5% of attorneys to the Super Lawyers lists each year. We know lawyers and make it easy to connect with them.

Find a lawyer near you