How the ACA Reshaped Employment Law and Health Benefit Claims
By Nancy Henderson | Reviewed by Canaan Suitt, J.D. | Last updated on October 15, 2026 Featuring practical insights from contributing attorneys William D. Frumkin, Eric J. Neiman, Jonathon Bashford and Caroline J. BerdzikBefore petitioners in King v. Burwell challenged the Affordable Care Act (ACA) before the U.S. Supreme Court during the 2014-2015 session (and lost), and before Republican members of Congress attempted to repeal or dismantle the ACA dozens of times following its passage, lawyers across the country were anticipating how the law would intersect with long-standing health insurance and labor statutes. William Frumkin, an employment and labor lawyer from White Plains, New York, was one of them.
For Frumkin, the existing law in question was the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). “ERISA, when it was passed in 1974, had a section called Section 5.10,” he says. “If you’re going to mess with somebody’s employment status to prevent them from getting a benefit, that’s a no-no.”
The ACA’s employer shared-responsibility provisions may impose a payment on an applicable large employer, generally one with at least 50 full-time employees, including full-time-equivalent employees, if it does not offer minimum essential coverage to at least 95 percent of its full-time employees and their dependents.
Lawsuits Involving ACA Requirements
“Guys like me that represent plaintiffs,” says Frumkin, “We’re thinking, ‘This is interesting. What if employers decide they only want to have 49 employees and have everybody work 29 hours?’ We figured that may happen. How’s that going to play itself out?”
This issue played out in a landmark class action lawsuit against restaurant and amusement chain Dave & Buster’s, which was accused of cutting employees’ full-time hours to avoid providing health coverage under the ACA’s employer mandate. Frumkin, one of the lead plaintiff attorneys, helped secure a $7.4 million settlement for impacted workers in 2019, making it a pivotal precedent for ERISA Section 510 claims.
Benefits Under ACA
The ACA offers other benefits. Coverage can no longer be denied for pre-existing conditions, children can remain on their parents’ plans (if it covers children) until age 26, and patients have the right to appeal a denial of coverage.
Many preventive care services remain available without cost-sharing, including mammograms, immunizations, and screenings for cardiovascular health and mental health. While these requirements have faced legal challenges over federal mandate authority, mandatory coverage for preventive care remains a defining pillar of ACA-compliant plans.
It’s the most significant overhaul of the American healthcare system since the 1965 passage of Medicare and Medicaid. Of course, with change comes complications.
If you’re going to mess with somebody’s employment status to prevent them from getting a benefit, that’s a no-no.
Clinical Integration and Bundled Payments
Some of it comes down to expanded demand. With ACA Marketplace enrollment reaching record highs of over 21 million people in recent years, and tens of millions more covered through expanded Medicaid, the healthcare system has faced ongoing provider shortages and structural capacity constraints.
Jonathon Bashford represents healthcare providers at Bashford Law in Seattle, and he articulates the seeming paradox of the ACA. “The ACA is supposed to save the government and save the citizens money, yet result in better care,” he says. “So that means that providers are being challenged to provide better care with less money. That’s tough.”
Over the past decade, this shift accelerated as providers moved away from traditional fee-for-service models toward value-based care and bundled payment plans. What began as a major structural shift under the ACA has become standard operating procedure across large health systems.
Benefits of the New ACA Model
The old model, says Francis Serbaroli, a healthcare lawyer with Greenberg Traurig in New York, had many problems “including financial incentives for physicians to order unnecessary tests and procedures instead of just those tests or procedures that the patient’s medical condition called for.”
The bundled payment plan, he adds, is “basically imposing more risk on the various providers. Among other things, it provides incentives for quality and efficient care, but imposes penalties for poor quality or unnecessary care.”
“The government will now essentially pay the hospital a flat fee for your hip replacement or your knee replacement, but that’s got to cover you from seeing your doctor to having your surgery to recovering thereafter — the physical therapy, any nursing home payment — everything is going to be included in that one payment,” explains Richard Watters, a healthcare attorney at Lashly & Baer in St. Louis.
“[The government pays] the hospital, and the hospital has to take on all those costs. So obviously the hospital now has to control what the doctor bills, nursing home bills, physical therapist bills, and what its own bills are, if it’s going to make any money off that regimen.”
“It’s really a dramatic change,” Serbaroli adds.
I really wonder if some of the people who are talking about repeal are thinking about what it would do to hundreds of thousands of people in the country who are now able to get insurance and get treatment, who previously wouldn’t have been treated or would have been bankrupt.
Clinical Integration
The push for better, cheaper care is also speeding up clinical integration. It includes hospitals buying or merging with physicians’ practices or other hospitals. In theory, this puts general practitioners and specialists on the same page — or at least in the same computer system. It’s one-stop shopping.
“They can all pull up your records and see your entire healthcare history,” says Watters. “That’s going to continue, and that will overall have an improvement on care.”
“One of the things that has happened is trying to sort out where the ACA goals end, and the antitrust laws start,” says Eric Neiman, a healthcare attorney at Epstein Becker & Green in Portland, Oregon. “While the ACA wants more efficient organizations and does encourage consolidation, it also wants lower cost. If you get too much consolidation, it drives cost up, because there’s no competition.”
“There are hospital mergers that have been challenged,” adds Serbaroli. “The Justice Department has sought preliminary injunctions. In some cases, the courts have granted them; in others, the courts have denied them. And when they’ve denied them, some hospitals have gone ahead and completed their merger in the hope that even if the court sides with the Justice Department, the merger will not be able to be easily unraveled.”
ACA’s Impact on Other Areas of Law
While healthcare attorneys are on the front lines of this shifting legal landscape, the ACA is affecting other areas of the law as well.
ACA and Immigration Law
Mira Mdivani, an immigration lawyer in Overland Park, Kansas, says that since the advent of the ACA, she has seen an uptick in one thing: questions. “In-house counsel and HR professionals are asking more questions about eligibility for their personnel. But we have not seen any serious issues maturing into conflicts.”
On the whole, Mdivani says the ACA has been good for her clientele. “Foreign nationals in the U.S. often face serious hurdles when they interact with the government. We can tell you Kafka-style stories of work-visa holders struggling to obtain driver’s licenses,” she says. Under the ACA, she adds, “A good effort has been made to clarify which immigrants and nonimmigrants are eligible to purchase insurance, which includes ‘lawfully present’ foreign nationals.”
In the years since, several states have used ACA Section 1332 innovation waivers and state funds to further expand exchange access and coverage options to broader immigrant populations regardless of status.
The ACA is supposed to save the government and save the citizens money, yet result in better care. So that means that providers are being challenged to provide better care with less money. That’s tough.
ACA and Employment Law
Caroline J. Berdzik, chair of Goldberg Segalla’s employment and labor practice group in New York, advises business clients. “A lot has calmed down now because compliance is pretty much done,” she says, adding that law practitioners are anticipating potential litigation down the road.
Berdzik doesn’t want to hazard a guess as to what type of litigation but expects it will be similar to discrimination lawsuits. “It’ll certainly depend on how amenable certain states will be,” she says.
“Businesses sometimes make decisions like, ‘All right, we’re going to have more of a part-time workforce.’ Is that discriminatory on its face? Or is it simply a business decision that that’s how a company is going to move forward in staffing?”
ACA and Insurance Rates
In the years following the ACA’s passage, many attorneys anticipated a rise in insurance rates. “The first year, insurance companies offered insurance products on the exchange, but they really didn’t know how much to charge. They were guessing at things like utilization,” says Ellen Stewart, a healthcare attorney at Spencer Fane in Denver.
“So all those people who didn’t have insurance before are actually using the services. The insurance carriers are having to pay out more in claims, and therefore the cost goes up in the subsequent year.”
While insurance carriers faced volatile losses and exchange exits during the early years of the ACA individual market, the exchanges have since stabilized into a competitive, profitable segment.
Major carriers that previously pulled back returned to the marketplaces. Current premium adjustments and rate debates are now driven primarily by rising prescription drug costs, medical inflation, and ongoing legislative discussions around federal premium subsidies rather than early pricing uncertainty.
A lot has calmed down now because compliance is pretty much done… Businesses sometimes make decisions like, ‘All right, we’re going to have more of a part-time workforce.’ Is that discriminatory on its face? Or is it simply a business decision?
ACA Provisions To Combat Fraud and Abuse
And then there’s fraud. “The ACA added a number of measures to combat fraud and abuse,” says Stephanie Marcantonio, an attorney at Sheppard in New York, who advises long-term care providers, senior housing lenders, and pharmaceutical companies. “The ACA put measures in place that gave a little more teeth to what can be done on the investigation side.”
As for the policyholder side, Bradley Levin, an insurance litigator for plaintiffs at Levin Sitcoff in Denver, continues to advise policyholders to be precise when filling out claim forms, in case things go wrong.
“When you get to a point where you have to file a lawsuit, if there are discrepancies, if there are things that are contradictory between what it is that you put down on a claim form and what it is that’s reflected in the actual medical records,” he says, “those are the kinds of things that a judge, or ultimately a jury, will latch on to. That’s going to go to your credibility.”
A Post-Pre-Existing Condition Society
But the biggest change since the ACA went into effect may be what insurance litigators like Levin are not seeing.
“We used to see claims where there have been denials based upon pre-existing conditions,” he says. “In the last couple of years, I haven’t seen any kind of claims like that.”
Many of the attorneys we interviewed have felt this change firsthand. Neiman knows a 3-year-old born with a serious vascular brain condition requiring repeated surgeries. “Because of the ACA, the child has gotten the treatment he needs, and will keep getting it, and the family has avoided financial ruin,” says Neiman.
Watters is the father of an adult daughter with a chronic illness whose insurability was previously questionable from job to job. “And now, because of that act, she can get insurance,” he says. “That’s something tangible that almost everyone can feel and see.”
“When I hear people say, ‘I’m going to repeal every comma of Obamacare,’ I really think that that’s not considering the human side of it,” Neiman says. “I really wonder if some of the people who are talking about repeal are thinking about what it would do to hundreds of thousands of people in the country who are now able to get insurance and get treatment, who previously wouldn’t have been treated or would have been bankrupt.”
Tips for Signing Up
- Go to healthcare.gov and type in your ZIP code to see what plans are available.
- Deductibles, co-pays, and other factors vary widely, so compare plans to determine which works best for your needs.
- Make sure your preferred physician is on the list of available providers, or be prepared to choose one who is.
- You’ll be asked how you want to pay — monthly paper invoice, credit card, etc. Have that handy. And if you’re eligible for tax credits, keep your projected taxable income for the year in which the policy will take effect nearby as well.
- The website generally confirms the application within minutes by email.
- Once the account is set up, be certain the information regarding your primary care physician is correct, as that doctor must refer you to any specialists.
- Call the customer service number on your account if you have any questions.
- Updates must be made online or by phone for changes in marital or income status.
Find Legal Help
Visit the Super Lawyers directory to find an experienced health law attorney.
What do I do next?
Enter your location below to get connected with a qualified attorney today.Additional Healthcare articles
- What Is Healthcare Law?
- How COVID-19 Affected Telemedicine Laws
- What Are Physician Gag Laws?
- What Counts as Healthcare Insurance Fraud?
- What the Law Says About Referral Kickbacks in Healthcare
- What Is Informed Consent? Do I Have To Accept Medical Treatment?
- Health Care Provider Liability for False Claims After the Escobar Decision
- Can Teenagers Make Healthcare Decisions? Age Limits and Requirements by State
- HIPAA and Protecting Privacy of Your Medical Records
- What To Do When an Insurance Company Denies Medical Treatment
- Drug Price Transparency: State and Federal Reforms
- Reproductive Health and Data Privacy: State and Cross-Border Protections
- Abortion Laws by State: Guide to Abortion Access and Restrictions
State Healthcare articles
Related topics
At Super Lawyers, we know legal issues can be stressful and confusing. We are committed to providing you with reliable legal information in a way that is easy to understand. Our legal resources pages are created by experienced attorney writers and writers that specialize in legal content in consultation with the top attorneys that make our Super Lawyers lists. We strive to present information in a neutral and unbiased way, so that you can make informed decisions based on your legal circumstances.
Attorney directory searches
Helpful links
Find top lawyers with confidence
The Super Lawyers patented selection process is peer influenced and research driven, selecting the top 5% of attorneys to the Super Lawyers lists each year. We know lawyers and make it easy to connect with them.
Find a lawyer near you