Can I Sue My Landlord for Personal Injuries?

Use these links to jump to different sections:

• Is My Landlord Responsible for Tenant Injuries?
• Can You Sue Your Landlord for Negligence?
• What Happens if My Friend is Injured While Visiting My Leased Apartment?
• Is My Landlord Responsible for Damage to Tenant Property?
• Steps to Take if Considering Suing Your Landlord
• Find a Personal Injury Attorney

Navigating the complexities of landlord-tenant relationships can be challenging, especially when personal injuries arise. Injuries can happen unexpectedly, but did you realize that landlords may be held liable for such incidents? Understanding the nuances of your rights and the potential for legal action is vital. In this article, we’ll outline landlord responsibilities, the conditions under which they can be held liable for injuries, and how you can take action if needed. For personalized advice tailored to your situation, contacting a lawyer is a wise step to protect your rights.

Is My Landlord Responsible for Tenant Injuries?

Whether a landlord is liable for tenant injuries will depend on where and how the tenant suffered the injury. Generally, all states require landlords to maintain their rental properties safely and habitable. This duty of care includes addressing hazards that could cause tenant injuries.

Landlords have a duty of care, which is a legal responsibility to take actions that will protect someone else. They must apply this duty to the common areas of their rental property. This includes stairs, railings, hallways, lobby, and lighting in the rental property’s common areas. Landlords also have a duty to maintain habitability. This is the livability and safety of the rental property. To adhere to this, landlords must maintain the structural integrity of the roof, electrical, and plumbing.

Steven H. Mezer is a real estate attorney at Becker law firm in Tampa, Florida, who focuses his practice on representing condo associations and homeowners associations. He offers valuable insight into the legal process: “Do they [potential client] have a good case? People will call and say, ‘Well, I’ve been wronged, and I want to file suit against them.’ I will ask, ‘What are your damages?’”

To have a legal compensation claim, a tenant would need to have verifiable damages. Otherwise, there is nothing for the court to give compensation for. If a landlord fails to adhere to their duty of care and maintain property habitability, they could be found negligent. This negligence can result in the landlord being liable for the tenant’s injuries, which are a direct result of the landlord’s neglect of an unsafe condition. There could be mitigating factors, such as the tenant’s actions contributing to the injury or the landlord’s lack of knowledge of the unsafe condition.

Can You Sue Your Landlord for Negligence?

Yes, depending on the facts of the situation, a tenant can sue their landlord for negligence. To have a successful claim, the tenant would need to prove the four elements of a negligence lawsuit.

1. Duty of care
2. Breach of duty
3. Causation
4. Damages

The first element is to prove that the landlord had a duty of care. A tenant can do this by showing the defendant is a landlord and has a legal obligation to maintain the property. To prove the second element of breach of duty, the tenant needs to show that the landlord failed to meet their legal duty. Typically, this is being aware of safety issues and failing to do anything. The third causation element connects the landlord’s failure to act to the tenant’s injury. The fourth element proves that the tenant suffered damages because of the injury sustained due to the landlord’s negligence.

What Happens if My Friend is Injured While Visiting My Leased Apartment?

If a tenant has a guest over to their rental property, it can be tricky to determine who is liable. The responsible party will depend on the circumstances surrounding the injury. If the tenant is negligent, they can be held liable for their guest’s injuries. Because liability can take some time to determine, the tenant should notify the landlord of the injury as soon as possible.

A landlord could be liable if the guest’s injury was caused by dangerous conditions that the landlord was aware of and failed to address. This could be a broken handrail meant to provide support and stability for a staircase or actually broken steps. It could be uneven concrete that creates a tripping hazard for the walkways around an apartment building. The tenant would need to have documentation showing they informed the landlord of the unsafe condition.

Another factor to consider is insurance coverage. The tenant may have renter’s insurance that covers liability and insurance claims of guests. The landlord should also have premises liability that covers injuries to guests on the property.

Injured tenants and their guests should consult a personal injury attorney to clarify their legal rights and potential party liability. Because each injury is different, a lawyer will review the facts, explain the applicable law, and outline how similar cases are handled. 

Is My Landlord Responsible for Damage to Tenant Property?

A landlord is not always automatically responsible for damage caused to the tenant’s property. Generally, the landlord could be legally liable for tenant property damage if the damage directly resulted from their negligence. For example, a landlord wouldn’t be liable for a house fire that was caused by a tenant’s candle. However, the landlord could be liable if a house fire is caused by faulty wiring that the landlord was aware of and failed to have fixed. Other common issues that the landlord can be liable for include safety code violations, implied warranty of habitability violations, neglected safety hazards, and environmental issues like mold. However, it is important to check the lease agreement and applicable state law. These two things can impact what the landlord is automatically liable for.

Another consideration is renters insurance. Commonly, tenant property damage is covered by their renter’s insurance, not the landlord. In many cases, rental agreements require the tenant to purchase their own renter’s insurance. The tenant’s failure to buy this insurance does not automatically make the landlord liable. 

Steps to Take if Considering Suing Your Landlord

If a tenant is considering suing their landlord for injuries or damages to their property, the first step is to speak with a personal injury lawyer. The umbrella of personal injury law is broad, so it is important to find a lawyer who represents clients with your type of claim. For example, you wouldn’t seek out a car accident lawyer. Instead, you may speak with a lawyer who represents individuals who experience slip and fall accidents.

The lawyer will ask for a copy of the lease, a description of the landlord’s actions, and for the tenant to describe the facts of the situation that led to the injuries or damages. The attorney will explain the legal process and the potential for a successful personal injury lawsuit. There will also be a discussion about the possible recovery of different types of damages. A tenant’s claim could include medical expenses, pain and suffering, or even wrongful death.

Mezer highlights the importance of considering factors beyond the wrongdoing and the financial cost of pursuing a claim. Potential claimants should consider what else they have going on in their lives. They may not have the time, energy, and mental bandwidth to take on a lawsuit. “One other factor that really does come into this is whether they have the ability to pursue a legal claim. They [potential clients] call, particularly on the plaintiff side, wanting to file a claim for damages. I will ask, do they have the ability to do it? That’s on multiple levels—whether it’s the financial part of it or whether they have other commitments.“

The lawyer will work with the tenant to gather documents and evidence that can price the tenant’s claim. Some evidence will document financial losses, such as medical bills. Other evidence will support the tenant’s claim of landlord liability, such as communications or pictures of the property. This will help show that the landlord didn’t take reasonable steps to maintain a safe property.

The lawyer will send a formal complaint on the tenant’s behalf to the landlord. After giving the landlord a reasonable amount of time to address the complaint, the lawyer can proceed to file a lawsuit. You may attend alternative dispute resolution procedures, such as mediation, as part of the legal process. If this fails, the tenant and landlord will attend a trial in front of a judge to present their arguments. The judge will make a ruling based on the evidence presented and the applicable law.

Find a Personal Injury Attorney

Understanding your rights as a tenant and your landlord’s responsibilities is vital for ensuring a safe living environment. From maintaining the property to addressing safety hazards, property owners have a legal duty to protect their tenants. If you’ve experienced an injury due to negligence on their part, you may have grounds for legal action. Don’t hesitate to seek professional legal advice; consulting with a lawyer can provide clarity on your options and help you navigate the complexities of filing a personal injury claim. Your safety and well-being deserve to be prioritized.

Visit the Super Lawyers directory to begin your search for an experienced real estate attorney.