What Is a Sidebar in Court? Legal Meaning Explained

A sidebar is a private discussion between the judge and attorneys during a trial, often called a bench conference. It lets lawyers address objections, evidence admissibility, procedural issues, or sensitive information without the jury hearing them. The judge decides whether to allow the conference, excuse the jury, or require the lawyer to continue in open court. The goal of a sidebar is to prevent jurors from being influenced by legally impermissible information.

If you or a loved one is involved in a criminal matter, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney in your area. An experienced lawyer is crucial to protecting your rights.

What Is a Sidebar in Criminal Court?

A sidebar in court, also known as a “bench conference,” is a discussion held at the side of the judge’s bench. The judge determines whether the attorneys can approach the bench. The judge can allow the sidebar, excuse the jury from the courtroom, or deny opposing counsel’s request and ask the attorney to proceed.

During this mid-testimony conference, the judge, prosecuting attorney, and the defense attorney confer. Sidebars usually occur during testimony or arguments when an issue needs a quick resolution. Common examples of sidebar topics include:

• Objections to evidence
• Legal questions about admissibility
• Scheduling or procedural matters
• Sensitive information that a party argues should not reach the jury

Were You Arrested? Get the Right Help Today.

When your freedom is on the line, you need the best possible representation. Use the Super Lawyers directory to find a top criminal defense attorney near you.

Find a lawyer today

Why Can’t Viewers Hear What Lawyers Are Saying?

A sidebar keeps information from the jury. Attorneys speak quietly, out of earshot of the jury, and often out of range of courtroom microphones. Sometimes white noise or static sound plays during broadcasts of a trial to mask the conversation. In some courtrooms, the sidebars occur in a physical location away from the jury box and gallery.

Why Is a Sidebar Kept Private?

A sidebar is kept private to keep information from the jury. It also keeps the public, the courtroom gallery, and television and media audiences from the private conversation.

However, the primary reason to keep the conversation private is to prevent the jury from being influenced by information that may not be legally admissible. Keeping certain legal arguments out of the jury’s hearing protects the trial’s fairness. The court does not want the subject of the sidebar to impact the outcome of the trial until a decision is made.

Is Sidebar Privacy Legally Allowed?

Sidebars are a fully accepted part of criminal law procedure. Judges have broad authority to manage courtroom proceedings, including sidebar meetings. This supports the judge’s ability to manage trial procedure.

A sidebar discussion between the judge and attorneys helps to maintain transparency. A court reporter can record the private discussion during the sidebar so that it becomes part of the official record. The conversation is then preserved for appeal and review, even though it occurs in private.

The Importance of Keeping Sidebars Private

A sidebar effectively keeps evidence from the jury. It prevents them from hearing prejudicial or inadmissible information. It also saves time by avoiding courtroom-wide pauses for legal debates.

Asking for a sidebar lets attorneys argue points candidly without performing for the jury. This is just another way to ensure a defendant’s right to a fair trial. It keeps the proceedings efficient and orderly.

The Purpose of a Sidebar in a Trial

The sidebar helps resolve legal issues quickly and quietly. It helps settle objections and evidence disputes so the jury considers only proper evidence.

A sidebar also helps handle sensitive or confidential matters and keeps the trial moving smoothly. They support the integrity of the justice system rather than hide wrongdoing.

Contact a Criminal Lawyer

Important decisions can be made in a sidebar. It’s just one part of getting a fair trial. An experienced attorney can make sure your interests are represented whenever critical legal issues arise. If you or a loved one is involved in a criminal matter, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney in your area.