Who Advocates for the Child in Court? Understanding Child Legal Representation

Children can have legal representation in court, but who speaks for them depends on the type of case and the laws of the jurisdiction where the case is filed. In some situations, a judge appoints an attorney for the child. In others, the court names a guardian ad litem or another advocate to investigate the child’s circumstances and recommend what serves the child’s best interests.

Parents often assume the judge simply hears both sides and decides. But in many cases, another voice enters the conversation: that of the child’s representative. The representative may interview family members, gather information, and provide the court with valuable insight before any final decision is made.

“One reassuring aspect of the system is that children often have independent legal representation advocating strictly for their best interests, separate from both the state and the parents,” says Missy Boyd, a family law attorney at Boyd & Early Family Law in Blue Bell, Pennsylvania.

Who Advocates for the Child in Court?

Children typically cannot represent themselves in court. Children are considered minors because they are under the legal age of majority, which is usually 18 but varies by jurisdiction. However, courts prioritize the child’s best interests, especially in family law cases. To protect children’s legal rights, several people can represent a child in court.

“For example, in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, the Montgomery Child Advocacy Project (MCAP) provides volunteer attorneys for children who are victims or witnesses of abuse. Similar organizations exist in major jurisdictions, like the Support Center for Child Advocates in Philadelphia,” says Boyd.

“Parents can take comfort in knowing that an independent advocate is solely focused on their child’s well-being and on navigating the court process with them.”

Who can represent a child in court depends on the type of case and the representation needed:

• Guardian ad litem
• Child representative
• Child’s attorney

The exact title and duties that people in these roles fulfill can vary by jurisdiction. States define their own procedures, which can lead to different child advocacy roles.

Get Top, Proven Family Law Representation

From adoption to divorce to custody and everything in between, find a top family law attorney near you in the Super Lawyers directory.

Find a lawyer today

Can a Child Have Their Own Lawyer?

Yes. In some cases, children can have their own independent legal counsel to protect their interests during a court proceeding. Whether a child receives independent legal representation depends on several factors, including the type of case, state law, the child’s age and maturity, and whether the judge determines an appointment is appropriate.

A child’s attorney generally performs many of the same duties as any lawyer representing a client. They may meet privately with the child, explain the legal process in an age-appropriate way, provide legal advice, present evidence, question witnesses, and advocate in court on the child’s behalf. Exactly what the attorney is expected to do depends on the laws governing the case and the purpose of the appointment.

One important distinction is whether the attorney is expected to advocate for the child’s expressed wishes or for what they believe is in the child’s best interests. In some jurisdictions, an attorney follows the child’s objectives just as they would for an adult client, provided the child has sufficient capacity to direct the representation. In others, the attorney’s role may differ depending on the child’s age, the circumstances of the case, or state law.

The terminology also varies across the country. Depending on the jurisdiction, the court may appoint an Attorney for the Child, Child’s Attorney, Minor’s Counsel, or another type of child legal representative. Although the titles differ, state law and the court’s appointment order define each role.

Parents can take comfort in knowing that an independent advocate is solely focused on their child’s well-being and on navigating the court process with them.

What Is a Guardian Ad Litem (GAL)?

A guardian ad litem (GAL) is a person appointed by the court to represent a child’s best interests during a legal proceeding. Depending on state law, a guardian ad litem may be an attorney, but that isn’t always the case. Their appointment is generally limited to a specific case and ends when the legal matter concludes.

Unlike a traditional lawyer, a guardian ad litem typically does not serve as the child’s legal counsel or advocate solely for the child’s stated wishes. Instead, the GAL investigates the facts, evaluates the child’s circumstances, and makes recommendations based on what they believe is in the child’s best interests, even if those recommendations differ from what the child wants.

As part of that investigation, a guardian ad litem may interview the child, parents, teachers, relatives, counselors, or other people involved in the child’s life. They may also review records and assess family dynamics to better understand the child’s needs and living situation. In some jurisdictions, courts may also appoint child and family investigators or other professionals to perform similar investigative functions, although their duties and authority vary by state.

Child Advocacy Services By State

When Will a Court Appoint Someone To Represent a Child?

A court may appoint someone to represent a child when a judge believes an independent voice would help protect the child’s interests or provide additional information about the child’s circumstances. Whether that happens depends on the type of case, the facts involved, and state law. Appointment is not automatic in every family court proceeding.

Courts are more likely to appoint a child representative in cases involving custody disputes, especially when parents strongly disagree about parenting arrangements or other issues affecting the child’s well-being. A judge may also consider an appointment in divorce cases involving contested parenting issues or allegations of domestic violence, where an independent assessment may help the court evaluate the child’s needs.

Child representation is also common in child welfare cases, including abuse or neglect proceedings, dependency matters, and foster care cases. Courts may appoint an attorney, guardian ad litem, or another representative in proceedings involving the termination of parental rights or certain adoption cases to help ensure the child’s interests are considered throughout the process.

Some courts also appoint child representatives in juvenile delinquency matters or other high-conflict cases. This helps the court understand the child’s perspective.

What Does a Child Advocate Actually Do?

A child advocate gathers information that helps the court better understand a child’s circumstances and needs. The exact responsibilities depend on the person’s role, the court’s appointment order, and state law. Still, the goal is generally the same: to give the court an informed perspective before it makes important decisions.

To do that, the child advocate may interview the people in the child’s life. This includes talking to the child, their parents, and other relatives. It could also include teachers, caregivers, coaches, and counselors. They may review the child’s records, such as school or medical records.

This information helps the advocate build a clear picture of the child’s life. In some cases, they visit each parent’s home to observe the child’s living environment and interactions with family members.

A child advocate also participates in the legal process by attending court hearings and, when authorized, submitting written reports or recommendations to the judge. Depending on the case, those recommendations may address issues such as custody, parenting time, placement, or services that could benefit the child.

Each case is unique, and so are the children’s needs. As a result, no two appointments will look the same. The court order and state law define the advocate’s responsibilities. The scope of their representation can be limited or extensive.

Does the Judge Have To Follow the Child’s Representative?

The judge doesn’t have to follow the child’s representative’s directives. The judge makes the final ruling. However, how much weight the judge gives to the representative will vary. Each judge has discretion when considering the testimony of the child’s representative.

Can Parents Ask the Court To Appoint a Child Representative?

In many jurisdictions, parents or their attorneys may request an appointment. Judges may also decide to appoint one on their own initiative. The court may hold a hearing to evaluate the situation and determine whether naming a child representative is appropriate.

The court will consider several factors to determine if the request is appropriate:

• Serious conflict between parents
• Abuse allegations
• Neglect allegations
• Child with special needs
• Older child expressing preferences
• Complex custody disputes

Who Pays for the Child’s Lawyer or Guardian Ad Litem?

Who pays varies significantly among jurisdictions. Possible payment arrangements could be the parents splitting the cost, one parent paying, government funding, or a court-appointed program.

In some situations, the representative may agree to a pro bono arrangement. In this type of arrangement, they perform the work free of charge. There is no nationwide set standard. Arrangements can vary from case to case because every situation is different.

Can a Parent Challenge or Remove a Guardian Ad Litem?

A parent may be able to challenge the naming of a guardian ad litem, but only through legal grounds. It isn’t enough to simply dislike or disagree with the person chosen.

While allowed reasons can vary by state, common grounds include conflict of interest, bias, failure to perform required duties, or ethical concerns. When making a claim, you need verifiable third-party evidence to support it.

Talk to a Lawyer

Whether the court appoints an attorney for the child, a guardian ad litem, or another advocate, the goal is to help the judge make informed decisions affecting the child’s future. An experienced family law attorney can explain how the law applies to your situation and advocate for your interests every step of the way.

Use the Super Lawyers directory to find a trusted family law attorney near you.