ER Misdiagnosis: Can You Sue an Emergency Room?
By John Devendorf, Esq. | Reviewed by Canaan Suitt, J.D. | Last updated on November 19, 2026Doctors in the emergency room have a duty to follow the medical standard of care. Deviating from accepted medical standards by misdiagnosing a patient and causing them harm is medical malpractice. Doctors and emergency departments can be liable for a patient’s injuries caused by diagnostic medical malpractice.
Doctors and hospitals rarely admit to misdiagnosing a patient, which puts the burden on the injury victim to contact a medical malpractice attorney to pursue their legal rights. For more information about suing an emergency room after a misdiagnosis, contact a local medical malpractice attorney.
Understanding Emergency Room Misdiagnoses
The emergency department (ED) is often the first opportunity for a doctor and medical team to diagnose a patient with an emergency medical condition. Emergency departments often begin with an initial triage assessment to determine which patients need the most urgent care and which can wait before receiving treatment.
A misdiagnosis can happen at any time during medical treatment. The initial ER assessment is the first chance for a doctor or hospital to avoid diagnostic errors, delayed diagnosis, or misdiagnosis. However, ER physicians must make fast decisions about patients based on limited information. EDs may have an increased rate of misdiagnosis because patients are often seen at the onset of their symptoms, and the full presentation of their condition has not yet developed.
ER doctors can continue to evaluate and change their likely diagnosis as they gather more information about the patient and their condition. Doctors do not need to make a final diagnosis in the ED, but they do need to make informed decisions about immediate treatment, testing, or potential hospitalization.
A doctor makes an initial assessment based on the patient’s complaints, a physical exam, medical history, family history, and medical records. Doctors often order additional diagnostic tests to make their initial assessment, including X-rays, CT scans, and blood tests. A doctor can also consult a specialist or seek a second opinion if they have questions about the patient’s condition. This is a common part of the diagnostic process.
Misdiagnosis rates can vary by disease and symptom presentation. According to a study from Johns Hopkins University, the “big three” most serious and common diagnostic errors are associated with cancers, vascular events (stroke and heart attack), and infections (sepsis and meningitis). These diagnostic errors can lead to death or serious, permanent disability.
When an ER misdiagnosis causes serious harm, injury victims can sue an emergency room and the treating physicians for medical malpractice. A medical malpractice lawsuit lets injury victims hold doctors and hospitals accountable for their errors and recover compensation for their losses.
How an ER Misdiagnosis Causes Injury
Misdiagnosing a patient in the emergency room can cause serious injury or death. Diagnosing the wrong condition can delay necessary treatment or expose patients to unnecessary and harmful treatments.
Failure to diagnose a patient or a delayed diagnosis can result in a premature discharge, in which the patient is told to follow up with their doctor. An ER patient presents with potentially life-threatening symptoms and the ER turns them away, telling them to see their doctor. If the patient has a serious health condition, delayed treatment can be fatal.
For example, some patients with appendicitis go to the ER with a fever, pelvic pain, and vomiting. Misdiagnosing the patient with stomach flu and discharging them can result in serious infection or death.
A delayed diagnosis in the ED could leave a patient with an untreated serious medical condition. The condition could get worse, causing permanent damage or death. A misdiagnosis could waste time and resources with unnecessary treatments that do not address the patient’s actual condition.
For conditions like cancer, delayed treatment allows the cancer to grow and metastasize, or spread to other parts of the body. A delayed cancer diagnosis can lead to tissue damage and reduce the likelihood of successful treatment. Patients may also have fewer treatment options if a delayed diagnosis worsens their condition.
Proving Emergency Room Medical Malpractice
Not every misdiagnosis is medical malpractice. A misdiagnosis in the ER may be malpractice if the emergency physician deviates from the medical standards of care. The elements of medical malpractice for a misdiagnosis include:
- The doctor owes the patient a duty of care
- The doctor breaches their duty of care by deviating from accepted medical standards
- The doctor’s diagnosis or misdiagnosis causes the patient’s injuries
- The patient suffers harm as a result of the ER doctor’s negligence
When a doctor examines a patient in the emergency room, the ER physician accepts the patient under the doctor-patient relationship. From that point, the doctor owes the patient a professional duty of care. Other doctors and specialists who examine or provide care to the patient in the emergency department also owe the patient a duty of care.
To prove a doctor breached their duty of care, you generally need a medical expert to testify that the doctor’s treatment deviated from the accepted medical standards of care. Doctors may have multiple ways of treating a patient, and choosing one option or another is not necessarily a deviation. However, pursuing treatment that other reasonable doctors would not pursue in the same situation may be a deviation.
Some states have a higher standard of proof for emergency room malpractice. Most states use standard medical negligence, but other states require a showing of gross negligence, recklessness, or clear and convincing evidence for emergency care errors. This makes it more difficult for injury victims to recover compensation after an ER misdiagnosis.
Who Is Responsible for an Emergency Room Error?
Liability for a diagnostic error in the emergency room is complicated because the patient often sees multiple healthcare providers in a short period. The injury victim or family members may not know who caused the error or which party is liable for damages. The potential parties liable for ER mistakes include:
- Doctors
- Surgeons
- Nurses
- Radiologists
- Hospital administrators
Even a brief stay in the emergency room may involve treatment and care by dozens of healthcare workers. During handoffs between ER physicians changing shifts, doctors are supposed to inform the oncoming doctor about patient status and provide accurate documentation of treatment, possible diagnoses, and follow-up care. A misdiagnosis by the initial diagnosing doctor may lead the continuing doctor down the wrong treatment path.
Hospital Liability for ER Errors
Hospital or emergency room liability can also depend on whether the emergency room doctor was an employee or a contract physician. Under vicarious liability, the employer is liable for the emergency room physician’s medical mistakes. However, some ER doctors are independent contractors and not employees.
If the emergency room doctor is employed by the hospital’s emergency department, the hospital is liable for the doctor’s negligence while acting in the course of employment. This also applies to negligence of nurses, emergency room technicians, and other ER employees. Injury victims can file a claim against the negligent doctor or employee, as well as against the hospital as the employer.
Hospitals are also liable for their own negligence in hiring or supervising. For example, a hospital hires an ER doctor with a history of substance abuse problems. If the ER doctor misdiagnoses a patient while under the influence, the hospital may be liable for negligent hiring or negligent supervision.
Some hospital emergency rooms prioritize profits over patient care. Understaffing is a common problem in emergency rooms and can directly impact patient safety. It can cause staff burnout, delayed treatment, and patient accidents.
Apparent Agency of Contract Physicians
Many hospitals claim they are not liable for ER errors because the emergency physician was technically a contractor, not an employee. The ER independent contractor physician defense is a way for hospitals to try to avoid liability. However, using contractor physicians is not an automatic shield from liability.
Even if a doctor is not an employee, the hospital could still be liable under apparent authority. Generally, employers are not liable for the negligence of independent contractors. However, under apparent agency, a hospital can be held responsible for an ER doctor’s medical negligence if it appears to the patient that the doctor works for the hospital.
Apparent authority in a medical malpractice claim varies by jurisdiction, but generally requires:
- The hospital representing the doctor as a hospital employee or agent
- The patient believed the doctor was a hospital employee
- A reasonable person in the patient’s position would believe the ER care was provided by the hospital or its agents
Mandatory ER Treatment Under the EMTALA
The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) is a federal law that requires hospitals participating in Medicare to provide basic emergency medical services, even if the patient cannot pay for treatment. This law prevents hospitals from dumping ER patients who cannot pay.
Participating hospitals must provide a minimum level of care, including a medical screening examination (MSE) when a request is made for treatment of an emergency medical condition. Hospitals must also provide stabilizing treatment, if necessary. If the facility cannot stabilize a patient, the hospital should make the appropriate transfer.
The EMTALA requires ERs to provide uniform screenings for patients for emergency medical conditions. MSEs must be timely, appropriate, and designed to identify emergency conditions.
Violations of the EMTALA are subject to civil fines. However, failing to admit a patient could be a medical error, even if it does not violate EMTALA. If failing to admit a patient to the emergency room violates the accepted standards of medical care and causes patient harm, the ER doctor may be liable for failure to admit.
Compensation in an ER Medical Misdiagnosis Claim
Emergency room injury victims file a medical malpractice lawsuit to recover financial compensation for their losses. Compensation includes economic and non-economic damages. Economic damages can include medical bills, lost wages, loss of earning potential, and future medical expenses. Non-economic damages can include pain and suffering, mental distress, and loss of enjoyment of life.
Challenges in an Emergency Room Malpractice Case
Injury victims face many challenges in getting fair compensation after an ER misdiagnosis. Doctors often do not admit fault, even if they know they misdiagnosed a patient. Some doctors even hide their errors to cover up ER negligence. Patients and their loved ones are stonewalled and have no other option but to pursue a medical malpractice claim to get answers and compensation.
Many hospitals have strict policies to deny and defend against any claims of wrongdoing. In many cases, a patient just wants some acknowledgment that something went wrong. As a result, patients are denied an apology, an explanation, more information about the cause, and any helpful plans to prevent it from happening again.
With so much at stake in a medical malpractice lawsuit, insurance companies and hospitals invest heavily in defending their cases. With so many defensive measures, it can take years for an emergency room malpractice case to go to trial. Injury victims must suffer their injuries without knowing when they will finally get a settlement offer.
Medical malpractice cases also have a much higher pleading burden than other types of personal injury claims. Most medical malpractice cases require an affidavit of merit or certificate of merit for filing the lawsuit. This may require a medical expert to certify that the injured party has a legal claim.
Legal Help from a Medical Malpractice Lawyer
An experienced emergency room malpractice attorney can help you meet these challenges and guide you through the process. Your attorney can explain the legal process, what to expect, and negotiate a strong settlement so you can move on with your life. Contact an experienced medical malpractice lawyer for legal advice about your ER claim.
What do I do next?
Enter your location below to get connected with a qualified attorney today.Additional Medical Malpractice articles
- What Is Medical Malpractice Law?
- How Long Do You Have To Sue for Medical Malpractice?
- How Much Is a Medical Malpractice Case Worth?
- Who Can You Sue For Medical Malpractice?
- When Should I Hire a Medical Malpractice Lawyer?
- What Is the Difference Between Medical Malpractice and Medical Negligence?
- What Are the Stages of a Medical Malpractice Lawsuit?
- What Are the Types of Medical Malpractice?
- How Will I Pay a Medical Malpractice Attorney
- How To Choose a Medical Malpractice Attorney
- Cosmetic Surgery Gone Wrong: Can You Sue a Plastic Surgeon?
- Dental Malpractice: Can You Sue Your Dentist?
- Missed or Delayed Cancer Diagnosis: Can You Sue?
- What Is Medical Battery? Suing for Treatment You Never Agreed To
- AI in Healthcare: Diagnosis Liability and Mandatory Disclosures
- Can You Sue a Therapist for Medical Malpractice?
- Can You Sue for Lack of Informed Consent?
- Can You Sue Doctors for Medication Addiction?
State Medical Malpractice articles
Related topics
At Super Lawyers, we know legal issues can be stressful and confusing. We are committed to providing you with reliable legal information in a way that is easy to understand. Our legal resources pages are created by experienced attorney writers and writers that specialize in legal content in consultation with the top attorneys that make our Super Lawyers lists. We strive to present information in a neutral and unbiased way, so that you can make informed decisions based on your legal circumstances.
Attorney directory searches
Helpful links
Find top lawyers with confidence
The Super Lawyers patented selection process is peer influenced and research driven, selecting the top 5% of attorneys to the Super Lawyers lists each year. We know lawyers and make it easy to connect with them.
Find a lawyer near you